Creating a Frictionless Organization & Better Customer Experiences

Creating a Frictionless Organization & Better Customer Experiences

Doing CX Right podcast show on Spotify with host Stacy Sherman
DoingCXRight-Podcast-on-Amazon-with-host-Stacy-Sherman.
Doing Customer Experience (CX) Right Podcast - Hosted by Stacy Sherman
Doing CX Right podcast show on iHeart Radio with host Stacy Sherman

Being frictionless has become a strategic necessity.

What does frictionless even mean? What are simple steps to remove customer pain points and get to a frictionless state based on learnings from the most reputable brands? 

Whether your company is a small start-up, mid-size or large corporation, the principles are the same, and it is in your control to improve experiences for everyone who interacts with your brand. In fact, customer loyalty depends on it.


Customer Service and Experience Topics discussed:

  • The definition of frictionless.
  • Why should business managers and leaders care?
  • Practical advice from Bill’s book: ‘The Best Service Is No Service,’  
  • Proven ways to reduce customer complaints by removing friction. 
  • Bill’s step-by-step methodology to remove customer pain points and sustain a frictionless state. 
  • Doing CX Right examples from companies all over the world, including Airbnb, Amazon, Tesla, Zoom, etc. 

Episode Timestamps

[04:18] Defining friction and the goal of becoming a frictionless organization

[05:31] Why managers must listen to live calls, chat threads, and recorded calls

[07:13] Asking “Has this happened before?” to identify repeat contacts (snowballs)

[08:18] The “best service is no service” philosophy from MCI and Amazon

[09:57] Splitting contacts into reasons and assigning ownership outside customer service

[11:27] Closing the loop by charging costs back to owning departments

[14:08] Omnichannel friction when online and retail teams have different metrics

[20:52] Journey mapping across website, app, chatbot, IVR, store, and contact center

[24:51] Preempt: sending two-way updates before customers chase status

[27:00] Leverage: using cancellation requests to learn root causes

 

Press Play To WATCH Interview:

Read Full Episode Transcript

Full Transcript:  

Creating a Frictionless Organization & Better Customer Experience 

[00:00:00] Stacy Sherman: Welcome to the Doing CX Right show. I’m your host, Stacy Sherman, a professional speaker and advisor, educating business leaders how to boost revenue and brand reputation the right way. Too many companies are losing customers and top talent and don’t know why.

[00:00:17] Stacy Sherman: Well, by listening to this show, you’ll gain valuable insights and precise strategies to close the gap and make experience management your competitive advantage. I’m diving deep into new research [00:00:30] and case studies to help you differentiate your brand in this high-tech era. Think of my show as your personal masterclass.

[00:00:38] Stacy Sherman: By the way, if you’re looking for a speaker at your next event, a content partner, or someone to ensure that your team is doing CX right for better results, contact me at Doing CX Right.comNow, let’s get started. Hello, Bill Price. Welcome to the Doing CX [00:01:00] Right show.

[00:01:01] Bill Price: Thank you, Stacy. I’m delighted to be here. I love doing CX right as well, so I’m happy to be joining you for this purpose.

[00:01:08] Stacy Sherman: And it’s kind of funny that as I’m getting to know you and talking about CX, I’m even defining what CX is, and I realize- Yeah … wait, look who I’m talking to. No, I don’t need to do that with you. Sure. So on that note, who are you? What do you do professionally? Tell my audience.

[00:01:25] Bill Price: Sure. No, thank you. I, um, I set up a, uh, boutique [00:01:30] customer experience and customer service consulting firm called Driva Solutions.

[00:01:34] Bill Price: Driva is a Swedish word that stands for to propel, to move forward. Uh, do that out of, uh, uh, Seattle, Washington, and I’ve got a crew of really experienced consultants and, uh, former practitioners around the United States, and I work with, uh, business partners in eight other countries as well, so we support global clients, too.

[00:01:53] Stacy Sherman: Hmm. Why your passion around this topic?

[00:01:58] Bill Price: Um, I [00:02:00] am fed up with poor customer service, poor customer experience. Some I face, I keep getting stories from friends who pour them over to me saying, “You need to look into this,” or, “Why is this happening?” And in some cases I can reverse engineer why it happened, but I’m still not pleased with, with the, the, uh, impact on friends and family.

[00:02:21] Bill Price: But, but moreover, it’s just that I, I’ve been fascinated with how customers interact with organizations and, and how it’s [00:02:30] almost like a, a, uh, different communication layers. The commun- the company or organization thinks it’s doing this, and the, and the customer doesn’t get it. They’re on a different wavelength, so trying to basically bring those two into sync is what’s one of my passions.

[00:02:43] Stacy Sherman: Hmm. What’s one fact that people may not know about you?

[00:02:49] Bill Price: Okay. Uh, one fact that you may not know about me is, um, uh, I grew up in Baltimore. Uh, I’ve been on the West Coast for a long, long time, but I grew up in Baltimore, and I’m a [00:03:00] 12th-generation Marylander. So I actually did my genealogy research when I was a kid.

[00:03:04] Bill Price: My cousin, Jay Geyer, we used to call each other cousin. We didn’t know whether we were cousins or not, so we, we traced back, and our great-grandmothers were sisters, so indeed we were cousins. And I just kept going. I kept going further and further back and, uh, so it’s, uh, fascinating to see the Price family so deep in Maryland.

[00:03:20] Bill Price: But I got away. I, I moved away to California in my 20s and, uh, and have stayed out on the West Coast. But that’s one thing you probably don’t know is I grew up on the East Coast.

[00:03:29] Stacy Sherman: [00:03:30] Hmm. And did you have any friction in moving to the West Coast?

[00:03:36] Bill Price: Um, you know, it was interesting question. No, because at that time I was still, uh, in the US Navy, so the US Navy took care of that for me.

[00:03:42] Bill Price: There was friction to get to the West Coast. The Navy wanted me to stay on the East Coast to finish out my tour of duty. Uh, this was between college and grad school, but I really wanted to get to the West Coast, so I kept pushing for them to get me an assignment on the West Coast, and I finally got one.

[00:03:56] Bill Price: So the friction was one of getting the position, [00:04:00] but once that happened, the Navy came in and grabbed all my stuff and shipped it out, and I drove out in my little car and it was fine. No. That, that, that was actually… It actually worked out pretty well

[00:04:10] Stacy Sherman: So you’ve stated that being frictionless- Mm-hmm … has become a strategy, a really important one for companies.

[00:04:18] Stacy Sherman: First, define what friction means to you.

[00:04:22] Bill Price: It’s, it’s, the question has come up a lot when, when we, when we reached out to about 15 or 20 companies, Stacy, who were, who are still very [00:04:30] well-respected for their customer experience and customer service. We, we asked them, “How do you do it?” Uh, and they gave us many stories.

[00:04:37] Bill Price: They talked about some technologies. They talked about some key individuals. But what they kept talking about was friction. In other words, they kept talking about their goal was, to your po- previous point, how do you identify and get rid of friction? It was only later on that we came up with the flip side of it that said, well, what they really were saying is they wanted to be frictionless.

[00:04:57] Bill Price: So we, um, we decided to flip [00:05:00] the title around and call it, uh, the frictionless organization, and, and it’s hard to know that you’re frictionless, but it’s easy to know that you cause friction. So what we talk about in the book is how do you define, measure and remove friction in order to become frictionless.

[00:05:16] Stacy Sherman: Mm. So why do you feel that managers, leaders should care- Mm-hmm … about focusing on friction? Because there’s so many competing deba- [00:05:30] demands on them.

[00:05:31] Bill Price: Sure. Well, o- one litmus test that we always do as consultants, I always used to do when I was running customer service at Amazon and back at MCI before that was, was listen to what the customer is telling you.

[00:05:44] Bill Price: And when you listen to, either listen in on live calls or look at chat threads or listen to recorded calls, you hear a great amount of frustration from customers. You hear it in their voice. They, they go through a problem, and then the agents, customer agent, customer [00:06:00] service agent says, “Well, I can’t help you today.

[00:06:02] Bill Price: You have to call me back later.” Well, that, that adds even more friction. And so most managers don’t listen to their customers anymore. They read reports, and they look at Pareto charts, they look at histograms, they look at summary data points, averages for things like customer sat or net promoter score.

[00:06:21] Bill Price: They don’t take the time to listen to what the customer’s actually saying. And what customers are saying is, “We’re frustrated with a lot of things that [00:06:30] your company does.” When managers do hear that, it’s like a light bulb goes off, and they, they start getting really action-oriented, but they’re not quite sure where to go.

[00:06:37] Bill Price: How do we fix that? So that’s what we try to address in the book, is try to catalog how to deal with it. But most managers just don’t take the time anymore, unfortunately. C- certainly senior managers, even less so, don’t take the time anymore to listen to customer, uh, direct customer, uh, inputs to what’s going on

[00:06:55] Stacy Sherman: So there’s a lot of questions when they are listening and they are getting [00:07:00] feedback.

[00:07:00] Stacy Sherman: There’s a lot of questions that you can ask customers. What are some of your favorite and, and your recommendations to be able to dig into is are you creating friction for your customer?

[00:07:13] Bill Price: Well, one, one way is, is to ask, “Has this happened before to you?” Because that starts leading down a whole path of, of repeat contacts, repeat issues.

[00:07:21] Bill Price: Mm-hmm. We, we use the term snowballs. It was a term we invented back at Amazon for repeat contacts. So w- snowballs, repeat [00:07:30] contacts are, are really serious. They’re, they’re damaging to the brand. Uh, they take a lot of time and effort. So one of the questions we ask is, “Has this happened to you before?” Now, in fact, the company should know whether it happened to the customer before, but it’s still useful to engage in a dialogue because customers will say, “No, this is the first time I’ve had it.

[00:07:48] Bill Price: I’ve had perfect experience ever, uh, in the past. This is the first time it’s been a problem.” Or they may say, you know, “Every time I deal with this particular product or this bill or this shipment type [00:08:00] issue, I always run across this.” Hmm. So that’s what– that’s a key question to start asking, and then, and then you can kind of go down the, the logic path of first time versus repeat or snowballs.

[00:08:10] Stacy Sherman: Hmm. You’ve written about the best service is no service.

[00:08:16] Bill Price: Right.

[00:08:17] Stacy Sherman: What does that mean?

[00:08:18] Bill Price: Well, back in the ’90s when I was running, uh, uh, some operations at, at MCI, at MCI Telecommunications Company, it, it, it struck me that the companies we work with, uh, and [00:08:30] the, the both… We was on, on the business customer side.

[00:08:32] Bill Price: The business clients we work with were ones that were– they were striving to reduce the need for contact. So I came up with this expression, “The best service is no service.” The best service is no need for service. In other words, things should work clearly. They should work smoothly. Uh, customers shouldn’t have to bother to contact themselves for a lot of the issues.

[00:08:52] Bill Price: And so when I, when I was interviewed by, by Jeff Bezos for this position, uh, at Amazon, which became Worldwide Customer [00:09:00] Service, VP Worldwide Customer Service, he asked me at the end of the i- actually beginning of the interview, at the end of the day, but beginning of his interview, he asked what was my philosophy for customer service.

[00:09:10] Bill Price: And I said, “The best service is no service.” And he said, “Yes, that’s what we wanna do at Amazon. We wanna make things simple, easy. They work well. When we make mistakes, we fix them, but we don’t wanna make mistakes.” So the concept of best service is no service is figure out what are some of those problems that, that, that are [00:09:30] causing mistakes and confusion, and just attack them and, and just get rid of them.

[00:09:35] Stacy Sherman: Hmm. How do you recommend people do that? It sounds so lovely. And e- and sounds simple, but we know it’s not.

[00:09:45] Bill Price: It isn’t. It is not simple. The, the, the first thing to do is to figure out what are those frustration points? So we call them reasons. Intense reasons. They go by different names, but let’s call them customer service reasons.

[00:09:57] Bill Price: So you split the whole range of why [00:10:00] customers are contacting you into reasons, and then you figure out which reasons are good for them and which reasons irritate them or frustrate them. And when you start splitting them like that, then you start zeroing in on the ones that frustrate them. And for the ones that frustrate them, and I’ll give you a couple of examples in a moment here, figure out who within the organization, outside of customer service, either caused that to happen and/or will lead the charge to fix it.

[00:10:26] Bill Price: So for instance, why is my bill so high? Well, that could be [00:10:30] because promotions were offered early on, uh, in the subscription period or early on in the relationship. Those, those promotions were, uh, uh, rolled off, and for some reason, the company did not tell the customer or the customer was meant to remember it, that in fact their bill is gonna go from $30 a month to $36 a month.

[00:10:48] Bill Price: Well, they’re, they’re watching their dollars, and they’re saying, “Why is my bill so high?” And that’s ’cause the company forgot to or didn’t even think about alerting them that your promotion is rolling off. It’s gonna go from [00:11:00] 30 to 36. Love having you as a customer. Hope this works for you. That might have allayed some high percentage of those reasons, but that’s not a customer service problem.

[00:11:10] Bill Price: That’s a billing or product or marketing responsibility. So get that particular reason over to the correct department so they can go, “Aha, well maybe we do have some ways we can reduce the need for that issue.”

[00:11:23] Stacy Sherman: Well, and then how do you get them to close the loop?

[00:11:27] Bill Price: Uh-huh. Close the loop is so important. [00:11:30] At, at Amazon, I was really helped by a CX metric, but the CX definition, Stacy, back there was actually called customer ecstasy.

[00:11:39] Bill Price: That’s how it was called at Amazon in the late ’90s, uh, late ’90s, early 2000s. CX meant customer ecstasy, and that’s what Jeff wanted. He wanted customer ecstasy, not just happiness, not just satisfaction. So in the CX orientation, what, what I was lucky to have around me with, within Amazon was once we had those [00:12:00] reasons, we could count them, we could cost them out, and then what we did is we charged them back to the owners.

[00:12:08] Bill Price: We charged them back to the head of billing or to the head of IT or to someone on the web- website design or someone in outbound shipping. So they actually bore the cost of it, and when they… Internally. And when they bore the cost of it, they became much more engaged to provide feedback to us to go back to the customer so that we could close the loop within the company, but [00:12:30] also back to the customer.

[00:12:32] Bill Price: With clients that I’ve worked with now over the years, some of them have gone that far, others have used a thread of it, which is usually enough, and others have just said, “Look, we have to work together on this.” This is a, as we call it in the book, a whole of business problem. Customer service is like the big catcher’s mitt.

[00:12:47] Bill Price: The rest of the organization has to then get that ball thrown to them so they can deal with it. And, and, and then the expectation, the requirement is then you have to analyze it, research it, and then come back either through [00:13:00] customer service or maybe even go directly to the customer. Mm-hmm. So, uh, a, a good friend of mine used to work at Costco, and, and he was an executive at a Costco warehouse before costco.com even came around.

[00:13:11] Bill Price: He said every morning he had to respond in person to customer complaints in the warehouses around the United States about his responsibility in the morn– the next morning, every one of them. And so he personally would then find out, “Well, what’s really going on? I understand you had a problem with this, that, or the other thing.

[00:13:28] Bill Price: I need to get more information. Tell [00:13:30] me more about it.” This was twenty-five years ago. So that type of, of orientation, culture, expectation is, is really what we’re talking about and trying to achieve to become frictionless too.

[00:13:42] Stacy Sherman: Mm-hmm. You talk about a lot of topics in that. I love it. One thing that stands out is around accountability.

[00:13:52] Bill Price: Mm-hmm.

[00:13:53] Stacy Sherman: And even though there’s a lot of different departments, that you’ve got to break [00:14:00] silos and get people to work together, including their goals, their common goals.

[00:14:07] delete: Right.

[00:14:08] Stacy Sherman: And w- it’s funny you mentioned MCI, uh, at that time. So I had worked for AT&T- Mm-hmm … and Verizon for half my career. Mm-hmm. And something that was really, that stood out to what you’re talking about is that our digital properties that people would buy online and then pick [00:14:30] up at store.

[00:14:30] Stacy Sherman: Mm-hmm. Well, what happened was your retail store had different goals and metrics- Right … than your online team.

[00:14:37] Bill Price: Exactly. Exactly.

[00:14:38] Stacy Sherman: Ouch.

[00:14:39] delete: Right.

[00:14:40] Bill Price: Well, and, and the thing is, it, it, it comes to… And I look at it, that type of story in this way, your customers know everything about your organization. Do you know what they experienced?

[00:14:50] Bill Price: In other words, and they may fill in the blanks and, and extrapolate or get a little more emotional than might be needed, but they, they are the ones who went on the [00:15:00] website, they ordered something, they went to the store, it wasn’t available, or someone couldn’t help them. Uh, uh, they’re the ones that have the history.

[00:15:07] Bill Price: Do you know their history? And that, that’s really it, the rhetorical question we’re trying to get companies to really ask themselves and try to figure out.

[00:15:15] Stacy Sherman: We, yes, and that’s where then personalization comes in- Right … because we would know, back when- Right … I was at Verizon, that- Right … if you came to the site and you logged in-

[00:15:24] Bill Price: Mm-hmm

[00:15:24] Stacy Sherman: you’re an iPhone user, I’m not gonna show you Android products.

[00:15:29] Bill Price: Right. [00:15:30] Right. Right.

[00:15:30] Stacy Sherman: Right?

[00:15:31] Bill Price: No, and, and it, it’s frustrating for a customer, and, and I’ll use, I’ll use that example. If you, if, if, if you’re a Verizon customer, you just bought a new phone, uh, and you’re excited about it, and, and you were instructed by the retail store or the telesales rep, whoever it was, to use the website for customer support or for i- issues you might have.

[00:15:49] Bill Price: If the first thing you saw when you come on the website is a promotion for a new phone, you just bought a phone. You say, “Well, wait a minute now. Is my phone not good anymore?” Or, “What happened here?” When in [00:16:00] fact, that was just sort of brochureware on the website that was not personalized. The personalized version would say, “Welcome to our club.

[00:16:07] Bill Price: Thank you, Stacy, for coming on board. Here are some f- FAQs for you. Here’s what you may see in your next,” we’ll call it journey. They don’t call it… You know, “the next step in your journey, you may need to do this or this or this.” And th- then you feel much more engaged in the whole process.

[00:16:22] Stacy Sherman: Yes, and when that customer who bought online now goes to the retail store-

[00:16:28] Bill Price: Right

[00:16:28] Stacy Sherman: that retail store [00:16:30] knows who that customer is, what they bought.

[00:16:33] Bill Price: Mm.

[00:16:33] Stacy Sherman: What a great opportunity to show them some accessories-

[00:16:37] Bill Price: Right …

[00:16:37] Stacy Sherman: because they know what they bought. Right. Right? Or-

[00:16:40] Bill Price: Well, and accessories are, are a wonderful thing, and also family members. You know, maybe-

[00:16:45] Stacy Sherman: Yes …

[00:16:46] Bill Price: your, your spouse or friend or son or granddaughter, whatever, they’re still on, pick another brand.

[00:16:53] Bill Price: And, and if they get you happy enough with Verizon, with whatever service that is, then maybe there’s also that big [00:17:00] move of, of, of an account over. But it’s only really knowing who you are, knowing what you’ve done with, with us so far. That’s, that’s what’s really important.

[00:17:08] Stacy Sherman: Well, going back to friction, so take that same customer, they go to the store, they pick up their product.

[00:17:16] Stacy Sherman: Most people are not technical in the way of knowing how to transfer their old phone data into their new one. Right.

[00:17:24] Bill Price: Right.

[00:17:25] Stacy Sherman: So what an opportunity for a company to say, “Oh, you just picked up your [00:17:30] phone. Let me help you- Mm-hmm … transfer it. Here’s what we can do together.” What an opportunity.

[00:17:37] Bill Price: It, it, it would, it would be such a game changer for that.

[00:17:41] Bill Price: And, and yet, as you said a few minutes ago, most retail store operations have a different metric, which is sales productivity, uh, or, or some other sales-type speed metric, when this is much more of a care concept. But they’re there in your store. You have them, they have a new, they have a new phone. A, a [00:18:00] related, you know, benefit for a customer, we can, can we give you some instructions how to make sure you can sync this up in your, in your car?

[00:18:06] Bill Price: And they might go, “Wow. Yeah.” So by the time you leave the store, not only is your, is your phone functioning, but you actually can make calls from your speaker in your car, or at least you can upload data. I mean, that type of value add is what most companies say they do, but they don’t necessarily follow through with it.

[00:18:23] Bill Price: And so customers notice when that does not happen, and that’s part of friction. But what they [00:18:30] love is when it does happen, and they may not even know that it’s frictionless. That’s the cool thing about this word we came up with is, is you know when friction is there, but you don’t necessarily know when it’s frictionless because things just work right.

[00:18:41] Bill Price: They just work smoothly.

[00:18:43] Stacy Sherman: Mm. That’s a great example. And I will say another point of friction, and an example for those who I guess are in a retail space or any company where you have omni-channel [00:19:00] That I get so frustrated, friction, that- … frustrated, whatever the word is, that when I go to return a product- Mm-hmm

[00:19:09] Stacy Sherman: I bought online, I go to bring it to the store to return, same company, they won’t let me return it. Wow. I have to leave and go send it back online. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. W- you’re one brand.

[00:19:22] Bill Price: That’s right. That’s right. What is this? Yeah. I- we work with a client, Stacy, in, in, in a, um, in the healthcare industry, and they did an offsite [00:19:30] meeting.

[00:19:30] Bill Price: They asked me to come down to talk a l- with them, which was really fun. Then they fanned out to a, um, to a shopping mall. Uh, and, and each person was, was equipped with a product to return, or an item to return to a particular store, and there were high-end stores like the Tiffany’s, there were, there were general retail stores like Macy’s, and there was Nordstrom, and a lot of other places were there.

[00:19:51] Bill Price: Lululemon, I mean, a whole bunch of different retail stores. And they came back afterwards, and their experiences were largely what you described. “This was something I bought. I had the [00:20:00] receipt. They still wouldn’t do it.” Or, “I bought it, and they didn’t have the receipt, and they wouldn’t let me do it.” But conversely, some of the other companies they went to said to them, “Well, it doesn’t matter if you don’t have a receipt.

[00:20:11] Bill Price: Let me look it up for you. Let me just get some information. No problem, you can return it.” So that A/B comparison is so useful to, to try to… And in this case, the company did it as their, as their, as their own, uh, example. But that, that, that’s the sort of thing where returns are, are very frustrating. It can be very frustrating, but when companies do it right, then you start [00:20:30] hearing the positive stories.

[00:20:31] Bill Price: They, they re- they took it back even though I didn’t have a receipt. Wow, I’m, I… Next time I’m gonna try to get a receipt, but at least they took it back for me.

[00:20:38] Stacy Sherman: Yeah. In the CX space, we talk a lot about journey mapping. What’s your perspective on journey mapping and- Mm … identifying those friction points?

[00:20:52] Bill Price: Thankfully now there’s some pretty good software out there that allows you to do journey mapping, but even if it’s traditional spreadsheet, [00:21:00] whiteboard, Visio diagrams, w- we think it’s really useful. I think it’s very useful to do it. The, the, the challenge always is going from channel to channel, the omni-channel point that you mentioned a little bit earlier, because a lot of journey mapping tends to be within a channel.

[00:21:15] Bill Price: Once you get to the, to the IVR in front of a contact center, what do you do? But most customers start way before that. So if you can capture in the journey what they actually did, which might be browsing online, [00:21:30] checking an app, navigating or dealing with a chatbot, and eventually an IVR, and eventually talking to someone in a store or a customer service center.

[00:21:38] Bill Price: So if it’s really true journey, then that’s really important. So it’s, it’s often good, it’s often useful, I think really important, to ask customers once they reach you at a retail shop or a customer service center, you know, basically, “Where have you been?” Again, the company should know, but most companies don’t know, and if you phrase it the right way, they’ll say, “Oh, this is, I, this [00:22:00] is my first time.”

[00:22:00] Bill Price: It’s almost like the first contact resolution example for, uh, uh, uh, snowballs and so forth. But they might say, “Oh my gosh, I tried this. I tried this. This didn’t work.” And, and, and so the frustration mounts up, so it can be, that it can be, uh, confronted. But I, I think journey mapping is, is very useful. Now, one, one, one PS on that one is, is different customers have different journeys, so there is no single journey.

[00:22:26] Bill Price: So as long as it represents different variations on the [00:22:30] theme, then you can start seeing what the real impacts are for the customer and what you can do about it.

[00:22:34] Stacy Sherman: Oh, very good point, and I do like to take a small number of personas and map out their experiences. So that’s true. You can’t do it for everyone.

[00:22:44] Stacy Sherman: It has to be that more typical representation. Right. The other thing about journey mapping is that it not only does it give appreciation of walking in that customer’s shoes and problem-solving- Mm-hmm … but it really drives [00:23:00] internal buy-in and internal solutioning together, breaking those- Mm-hmm … silos and the domino effect.

[00:23:08] Stacy Sherman: You agree?

[00:23:09] Bill Price: Oh, y- I really do. I really do. We, we, w- we did work for, for a client once that was in the, um, in, in, in the retail business. Uh, and, uh, they, they had retail shops, and they had online. So almost to your point earlier about Verizon in a way. And so we, we, we came up, one of my, one of my teammates came up with a- Uh, the life of a [00:23:30] return.

[00:23:30] Bill Price: It actually took the position of a box being returned by the customer and where that return had to go, and where it was basically being inspected or where it got held for a while, and, and what triggered the refund to the customer, and how late was that after the customer actually returned the product to them.

[00:23:47] Bill Price: And, and it was such a complex Visio diagram that took, that took up so much time, it was inevitable the customer was gonna, was gonna ask frequently along that path, “Well, where’s my refund? [00:24:00] Where’s my money?” Or, “Where’s my replacement?” If in fact a replacement would be possible. And only when that was displayed on the board did those executives go, “This is really complicated.

[00:24:09] Bill Price: We had no idea that we were putting this return, this box, through all those different issues.” So you can do– you can do journey mapping of, of boxes too. It’s, it’s, it, it really can be quite illustrative

[00:24:22] Stacy Sherman: You have a methodology that you talk about in your book, and it’s really that step to s- step-by-step [00:24:30] guide.

[00:24:30] Stacy Sherman: Right. Um, as we’re coming to the end, do you want to share any examples or-

[00:24:36] Bill Price: Sure …

[00:24:36] Stacy Sherman: uh, a preview to the movie, the preview to the book?

[00:24:40] Bill Price: I’ll, I’ll, uh, there, there are nine steps, but let me just, let me talk about one of them, because it’s, it’s, it’s one that we have found to be incredibly powerful and, and not, not well understood, and that’s one we call preempt.

[00:24:51] Bill Price: And, and, and it, it- at the basics it is, if you know something that your customer does not know yet, then let them know. Put them in [00:25:00] charge of what to do about that. Don’t just let them wait to figure out that a flight is delayed, or a product’s not gonna arrive on time, or the promotion is being rolled off, as I mentioned earlier.

[00:25:11] Bill Price: Let them know, and, and with permissions, I mean, you need to have the right permissions to text them or to call them or email them or however you want to communicate with them, maybe post something on their app. But let them know. That preempt is a way to kind of dull the, the frustration. It doesn’t get rid of it, but it [00:25:30] dulls it some, and if you make it two-way, so the key thing is not just a one-way s- SMS or a one-way email that says, you know, “Cannot be return,” you know, “You cannot respond to this email.”

[00:25:42] Bill Price: So it needs to be a two-way street. Open up that communication to say, “We’re gonna let you know something that’s important for you, and, and we’re gonna allow you to give us some feedback on that if you want to.” Most customers go, “Okay, thank you. I’ll wait until you give me the final update.” So preempt is one of the nine steps we’re really got some great examples of that in the book, too.[00:26:00]

[00:26:01] Stacy Sherman: I love that example, and communication- Mm-hmm … the emphasis on communication because of, I can’t even say how many thousands of surveys and focus groups- Mm … and all those that I’ve been involved in, how communication, or lack of, is the number one pain point.

[00:26:22] delete: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

[00:26:23] Stacy Sherman: It is. And that’s in our control.

[00:26:25] Bill Price: Just let me know.

[00:26:26] Bill Price: That’s right. And, and, and customers are saying that, too. They’re saying, “Just let me know. [00:26:30] Just let me know and, and I’ll feel better about it.” So, uh, if, if products are gonna be delayed, if multiple, if, if an entire batch are gonna be delayed, you let the customer know. Mm. And, and they can either make other arrangements or they can wait, but at least they won’t be sitting there tapping their foot calling you or firing off a chat message to, to find out what’s going on.

[00:26:48] Bill Price: Just, just let them know.

[00:26:50] Stacy Sherman: All right, one more. Give us one more. That was the first one. Tease us with the second.

[00:26:55] Bill Price: All right. Sec- second one, second one I’ll, I’ll tease you with is, is, is called [00:27:00] leverage. So leverage is, is one where on the surface it’s, it’s good for the customer and it’s good for you to talk to each other.

[00:27:08] Bill Price: So it, it, it… There aren’t too many of these examples, but one of them would clearly be, “Tell me more about your products.” Another one would, would be, “I, I’m not sure if this really works for me. Can, can you tell me if, if this really fits my needs?” Those are great questions to have, and you should basically get rid of all timestamps and, and, and all limits and just, and do, have a good conversation, whether it’s done [00:27:30] electronically or, or in person.

[00:27:32] Bill Price: But another one that I’ll put in the leverage category, which is a confusing one to some, is, “I wanna cancel my product,” or, “I wanna cancel my account.” Some companies make that real easy. Punch this button and you can cancel. But other companies make it really, really hard by putting you through a saves queue and making it really hard for you to leave and, and not giving your, you know, not g- letting you cancel your account or whatever it is.

[00:27:55] Bill Price: The middle ground is what we’re seeking in leverage, which is, “We’re really sorry to hear about that, Stacy. You know, [00:28:00] why, why is it that, that you need to cancel your product? Maybe we can, we can do something about that.” But inside of it, they, they take that as, as the beginning of, like, a root cause analysis.

[00:28:10] Bill Price: So if cus- if, if a number of customers say, “I need to cancel my account because my bill’s always wrong,” or, “Because my system keeps dropping,” or, “Because you’re always late,” then you can start forming these patterns. So not just try to save that customer, which is really important, but deal with [00:28:30] other customers who may be similarly situated by really having that engagement of why.

[00:28:34] Bill Price: Why is this going on? Not to stop them from canceling necessarily, but to learn from, from what’s going on. Again, communication. It’s, it’s… So you could have them push a button that says cancel. That could be very simple, very easy, digitally click, you know, easy sol- uh, e- slick solution, but you’re not learning from it.

[00:28:52] Bill Price: So how can you learn from it?

[00:28:54] Stacy Sherman: So my head goes to communication again, and really good training [00:29:00] of your agents to ask the right questions to get to the why.

[00:29:04] Bill Price: They need to know that they can ask that, because some agents feel- Yeah … pressured that they have to get to the next call or the next chat session.

[00:29:11] Bill Price: Mm. But for the le- So it’s going back to these, this differentiation among reasons. For certain reasons, you deal with them a certain way, but for leverage reasons, basically take the time it needs and, and, and really have a, have a good conversation.

[00:29:26] Stacy Sherman: All right. Well, getting to the end, my final questions for you.

[00:29:29] Stacy Sherman: Mm-hmm. [00:29:30] If I had tons of leaders and CEOs in my room right now- Mm-hmm … at reputable brands, what’s the one takeaway you want them to remember?

[00:29:42] Bill Price: I would say to them, experience your own products as a customer does, either by literally experiencing them, by buying things incognito or by watching things, uh, uh, that, that happen in your, in your organization, or listening to [00:30:00] calls that are live from customers, uh, going into retail shops and, and, and listening to the conversations that happen when, when someone walks into your shop.

[00:30:07] Bill Price: So get that personal experience, whether you’re CEO, whether you’re a director of marketing, whether you’re a, a product manager, just get out there. One of my first white papers I wrote a long time ago when white papers were the thing was get out there. Just get out there. Move away from your office environment, or if you’re working from home, even move away from your home office and just get out there and experience it [00:30:30] from the customer point of view as much as possible.

[00:30:32] Stacy Sherman: Hmm. Absolutely. And in your employee’s shoes and agent’s shoes, too. Oh, yeah.

[00:30:38] Bill Price: Oh-

[00:30:39] Stacy Sherman: But that’s another- It be- … that’s another episode.

[00:30:41] Bill Price: It is another episode, but you learn about that as well at the same time,

[00:30:44] Stacy Sherman: right? Yes. And leadership advice, what’s the best-

[00:30:49] Bill Price: Mm-hmm …

[00:30:51] Stacy Sherman: that you’ve received or given?

[00:30:53] Bill Price: It was actually a long time ago.

[00:30:55] Bill Price: I started my career with McKinsey and Company, the big international consulting firm, and I worked with Tom [00:31:00] Peters. And Tom was very, very bubbly. He had lots of great quotes and examples, but he kept saying to clients of ours, and even to us as consultants, “If it’s not broken, break it.” Meaning, if you think things are working well, it may be a slippery slope down.

[00:31:18] Bill Price: So you have to keep challenging what’s going well to make sure that it continues to go well, and you have to reinvent what you’re doing so you don’t become complacent. So we have an example in the [00:31:30] book of the, the, the founder of Zoom was actually an executive at Webex, which is inside of Cisco, and he wanted a simpler Webex when he was working there back in the mid-2000s, maybe 2010, ’12 or something.

[00:31:46] Bill Price: And Webex said, “Nah, you know, everything’s working great, you know, we’re, we’re top of the game. Webex is a great system. People are buying it.” And he couldn’t convince them, so he left and formed Zoom, and he wanted to have a simpler product. So the idea was [00:32:00] just he, he wanted to reinvent it. He wanted to shape it up.

[00:32:03] Bill Price: He wanted to break it, even though at that time, Webex was doing perfectly fine. Now Zoom is one of the leading brands, and everyone’s trying to chase after them. So if it’s not broken, break it would be my point of view, uh, because you’ll learn a lot about that in the process.

[00:32:18] Stacy Sherman: Final question. If you could go back in time to your younger 20-year-old self, based on what you know now that you didn’t know then, what would you tell younger Bill Price?[00:32:30]

[00:32:30] Bill Price: I would say get my hands dirty. Get out of the, uh, consulting, which I did do after a few years, but actually go out there and, and run something. Figure out how- Mm … it works from the inside. Um, I was glad I did that. I became CFO for a startup company that MCI acquired, which is how I got into the telecommunications world, uh, as, as well as the customer experience world.

[00:32:53] Bill Price: But, but it was only because of that, um, well, the CEO, Ken Jones, who hired me in that position, that I was able to then [00:33:00] move away from what I’d been doing and, and actually got my hands involved in things, and I, I learned so much by being directly involved.

[00:33:07] Stacy Sherman: Great advice. Well, I know people are gonna wanna reach you and find you, and where’s the best place?

[00:33:13] Stacy Sherman: I’ll add it to the show notes.

[00:33:15] Bill Price: Well, we have, uh, my coauthor and I have a, a book site called frictionlessorg.com, and that’s a good place to learn about the book. Uh, you can find links over to, to me and to my coauthor, David Jaffe, who lives in Melbourne, Australia. Uh, and, uh, that- that’s a [00:33:30] good way to, to get ahold of us.

[00:33:31] Bill Price: And my email address is always available, bill@drivasolutions.com. Uh, so both of those are good ways to reach me.

[00:33:38] Stacy Sherman: Well, thank you for sharing such great wisdom today. I know people are gonna benefit, and I appreciate you.

[00:33:46] Bill Price: Thanks, Stacy. It was a really, really fun time. Thanks for your great questions and, uh, and, and, and the conversation.

[00:33:50] Bill Price: Loved it.

[00:33:51] Stacy Sherman: Thank you so much for joining today. I hope you’ll take what you’ve learned and put it into action, because it’s about doing CX right, not [00:34:00] just talking or thinking about it. If you found this valuable, leave a review wherever you listen to podcasts, as it helps others discover the show, and continue learning by subscribing to my newsletter and scheduling time with me to discuss anything on your mind.

[00:34:17] Stacy Sherman: Reach out at doingcxright.com. Thank you again. To be continued

 

Customer Experience Questions & Answers: What Leaders Need to Know

Q: How do we separate first-time issues from repeat contacts that signal a deeper problem?

A: Ask customers during live calls and chat sessions whether this issue has happened to them before. Record the answer in the contact reason field so you can count how many customers report the same problem in previous cycles. Customers who say this is the first time indicate an isolated incident. Customers who say they run into this every time with a particular product, bill, or shipment type indicate a snowball that requires a process fix. Use that count to prioritize which reasons to assign to billing, product, marketing, or operations for resolution.

Q: How do we assign ownership for customer problems that originate outside customer service?

A: Split all customer contacts into reasons such as billing surprise, promotion roll-off, website confusion, shipment delay, or return refusal. For each reason, identify the department that caused it or can fix it. Examples include billing for promotion notifications, marketing for offer terms, website design for navigation issues, outbound shipping for delivery delays, and retail operations for return policies. Assign the cost of each reason to that department in your weekly operating report so the owner sees the impact and participates in the fix. Require that department to analyze the cause, implement a change, and communicate the outcome back to customer service or directly to the customer.

Q: How do we map journeys that reveal friction across online, app, store, and service channels?

A: Build journey maps that start before the customer reaches the contact center. Include browsing on the website, checking the app, navigating a chatbot, interacting with the IVR, visiting a store, and speaking with an agent. Map variations for key personas instead of trying to capture every possible path. Add operational steps such as inspection, approval, and refund triggers for processes like returns. When executives see the full sequence of handoffs, they recognize where customers will ask for status and where delays occur. Use that map to remove unnecessary steps and to add proactive updates at points where customers would otherwise chase information.

Q: How do we prevent customers from contacting us about delays, price changes, or shipment issues?

A: Send two-way updates before customers need to ask for status. Notify customers when a flight is delayed, a product will not arrive on time, or a promotion is rolling off. Use channels where you have permission to reach the customer, such as text, email, phone, or in-app message. Design the update so the customer can respond, not just receive a one-way notice. That reduces the number of calls and chats where customers ask what is happening and gives them a chance to make other arrangements or confirm they will wait.

Q: How do we turn cancellation requests into learning that improves retention for other customers?

A: When a customer requests cancellation, ask why they need to cancel and record the reason in a structured field. Look for patterns such as bills that are always wrong, systems that keep dropping, or deliveries that are always late. Use those patterns to initiate root-cause analysis in the departments that own billing accuracy, system reliability, or delivery performance. Fix the underlying process so other customers in similar situations do not encounter the same problem. This approach treats cancellation requests as data that improves the experience for the broader customer base, not just as saves opportunities for the individual customer.

 

About Bill Price ~ The Frictionless Organization

Bill Price started Driva Solutions in September 2001 to help companies achieve the delicate balance between cost containment and greater customer loyalty, co-founded the 9-country LimeBridge Global Alliance in early 2002, and is the lead co-author of three books: The Best Service is No Service, Your Customer Rules!, and The Frictionless Organization. Bill served as Amazon’s first Vice President of Global Customer Service and before that was Vice President & General Manager of MCI Call Center Services, COO & CFO with a start-up software company in San Francisco, and a Senior Engagement Manager with McKinsey & Company in San Francisco and Stockholm. Bill received his undergraduate degree from Dartmouth College and his MBA from Stanford University, and lives in Bellevue, Washington.

Learn more about Bill Price on his website.  Connect on LinkedIn 

About Stacy Sherman: Founder of Doing CX Right℠‬

An award-winning certified marketing and customer experience (CX) corporate executive, speaker, author, and podcaster, known for Doing CX Right℠. She created a Heart & Science℠ framework that accelerates customer loyalty, referrals, and revenue, fueled by engaged employees and customer service representatives. Stacy’s been in the trenches improving experiences as a brand differentiator for 20+ years, working at companies of all sizes and industries, like Liveops, Schindler elevator, Verizon, Martha Steward Craft, AT&T++.   Stacy is on a mission to help people DOING, not just TALKING about CX, so real human connections & happiness exist. Continue reading bio >here.

How to Orchestrate Better Customer Experiences with Agentic AI

How to Orchestrate Better Customer Experiences with Agentic AI

Doing CX Right podcast show on Spotify with host Stacy Sherman
DoingCXRight-Podcast-on-Amazon-with-host-Stacy-Sherman.
Doing Customer Experience (CX) Right Podcast - Hosted by Stacy Sherman
Doing CX Right podcast show on iHeart Radio with host Stacy Sherman

      Most leaders think they are delivering a great customer experience. Pierre Charchaflian of IBM says they are delivering yesterday’s version. The new standard is not fixing problems when customers report them. It is knowing about the problem before the customer does, and solving it before they have to ask. That shift, from reactive to anticipatory, is what separates the brands that customers stay loyal to from those they leave without explanation. The technology to do it exists right now. Most companies are not using it. Pierre has spent 25 years at the intersection of data, technology, and customer experience, and he says this transformation is unlike anything he has seen before. The window to act is open. It will not stay that way. (IBM Partner.)

      What You Will Learn About Agentic AI and Customer Experience:

      •       What agentic AI actually is in plain language, why it is fundamentally different from prior AI capabilities, and what it means for your CX strategy starting now
      •       Why IBM’s research found that technology stack limitations, not budget or talent, are the number one barrier preventing CMOs from delivering the customer experience they already know they need to deliver
      •       How agentic search engines are becoming a direct threat to brand digital presence, and what leaders need to do before their customers’ AI agents start bypassing them entirely
      •       Why anticipating a customer’s need before they express it is now a measurable competitive advantage, and what separates the companies building that capability from the ones still reacting
      •       How AI can read sentiment, detect frustration signals across structured and unstructured data, and trigger a response before a customer decides to leave
      •       Why conversion is the metric that tells the truth about whether your customer experience is actually working, and what NPS and CSAT consistently miss

        Actionable Takeaways From This Doing CX Right℠  Podcast Episode:

        1.   Identify one customer signal your company already has but cannot act on, and map what it would take to connect it to a customer profile.
        2.   Audit your technology stack for silos, including AI tool silos, where different tools across different functions are not sharing data with each other.
        3.   Track one behavioral metric alongside your current CX measures: conversion rate, repeat purchase rate, or churn by segment.
        4.   Stop framing AI investment as an efficiency play in isolation. Make the case for anticipation as a revenue driver.
        5.   Define what your company will do with customer sentiment data from service transcripts, reviews, and social channels before you collect more of it.
        6.   Map which functions would need to collaborate to execute a single proactive customer intervention, and identify the executive who would need to sponsor it.
        7.   Evaluate whether your current CX strategy is built to respond to customers or to get ahead of them. Those are not the same strategy.
        8.   Have one cross-functional conversation this week about a specific customer situation where your company has the data to act and is not acting on it.
        9.   Build the case for trust as infrastructure: your data privacy practices and your CX strategy are the same conversation, not separate ones.
        10. Start preparing your brand for the agent-to-agent economy now. The brands’ customers already trust will be the ones their AI agents are authorized to engage.

        Press Play  To WATCH On Youtube

        Win The Moment by Mastering Customer Intent

        Agentic AI makes recognition, anticipation, and confidence possible at scale, but only when orchestrated across the right data, workflows, technology, and cross-functional alignment.  Download IBM”s newest report revealing how enterprises are restructuring operations around the intent economy. They explore three imperatives: turning fleeting signals into actionable intent, orchestrating personalized experiences before customers ask, and pairing speed with governance to compound advantage.

        Win the moment IBM report: Stacy Sherman and Pierre Charchaflian Discuss In Detail on Doing CX Right℠ podcast

        Doing CX Right Podcast Topics with Timestamps   

        • [02:00] What Doing CX Right means in the age of generative AI and why the definition is shifting
        • [05:23] Why anticipating customer needs is the next frontier and what is blocking most companies
        • [07:51] The AI silo problem and how it compounds the human and data silos leaders already have
        • [10:48] IBM’s “Winning the Moment” report: competing when agentic search engines start transacting for customers
        • [13:19] What agentic AI actually is, defined in plain language with a concrete CX example
        • [16:15] Where emotion and customer sentiment fit into AI-driven experience design
        • [19:58] Why conversion beats NPS and CSAT as the metric that connects CX to revenue
        • [21:45] Why executive leadership, not technology, determines whether CX transformation succeeds
        • [25:55] The vision Pierre is driving with every CMO he works with right now
        • [26:11] What Pierre would tell his 20-year-old self about risk and career

        Read Full Episode Transcript


        Stacy Sherman: Hello, Pierre. Welcome to the Doing CX Right show.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Hi, Stacy. Thank you for having me.

        Stacy Sherman: I’m excited you are here, and I want my audience to know that we got to meet in person, which is a rarity for me. People on my show, I usually meet them after, not before, and so this is super special.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah, same here. That’s awesome that we were able to connect in person, and we get to continue the conversation.

        Stacy Sherman: Yes. Well, before we dive deep into the topics, Pierre, tell everyone, who are you? What do you do for a living?

        Pierre Charchaflian: Sure. Pierre Charchaflian. I’ve been at the intersection of data, technology, marketing, and customer experience my entire life. I’ve lived through several evolutions and reincarnations of marketing, digital [00:01:00] marketing, and customer experience, and now we’re living through the generative AI transformation. Lots of lessons to learn from, lots of lessons to leverage, but not a bit less excited about how we can help organizations and brands transform themselves, given the dynamics and the great opportunities that generative AI is affording us.

        Stacy Sherman: Yes. So I got to learn firsthand so much good — I call it gold — of content and lessons from joining IBM at Adobe Summit, and it was… I was like a kid in a candy store, really. It was so informative. Share a little bit about what you were focused on at the summit.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah. So obviously you can’t have a transformation conversation today in marketing or customer experience without generative AI. And being at [00:02:00] IBM, sort of the OG of AI with Watson and now WatsonX, really our focus was to drive our point of view and our capabilities around what do brands need to do, and can and should do, to position themselves to win in the future with generative AI on two levels. How to transform your internal marketing operations and processes and operating model. But as, if not more importantly, how do you transform your customer experience and be able to derive a competitive advantage leveraging generative AI, which hopefully we’ll get a chance to talk a little bit more about in today’s session.

        Stacy Sherman: Yes, and I want to, during our talk, define what is this agentic and orchestration and all these big words, because not everybody understands, but yet fundamentally they know it’s important and they’re saying, “I should know, but I don’t know enough.” So we’re going to help them out. Before I do, my question for you is, this is the Doing CX Right show, so [00:03:00] therefore I need to ask you, what does doing CX right mean to you?

        Pierre Charchaflian: Really good question. You know, I joke, and I’ve been in this business for a long time, a quarter of a century at least, and I joke and I tell people I’ve been doing the same thing and selling the same thing and helping companies do the same thing: right offer, right person, right time. But I think doing CX right is very contextual based on what data you have at a given moment. I think we have an incredible opportunity to do CX right in the age of generative AI by not only delivering on what customers want, but actually anticipating what customers want. You know, generative AI has this incredible capability of understanding intent and deciphering meaning. And with that, we can not only understand what you want, but actually anticipate and really get you beyond just a blue shirt, but an entire outfit in your commerce experience, right? As a small [00:04:00] example of curating not only a seat on a plane, but curating an entire trip that you’re taking with an entire itinerary, and really be able to expand the aperture of what brands can do to round out the experience and the services that we deliver to you. And the brands that will be able to manage that and deliver on that, I think will have an incredible strategic advantage. So doing CX right today and in the future is not only the right person, right offer, right time, but anticipating the need that will drive the right person, right offer, right time. So that’s the key word that I would say in the pivot of CX today and in the future, is the ability to understand intent and anticipate customers’ needs in this really exciting age of technology.

        Stacy Sherman: So anticipate, get ahead of, solve people’s needs before they even realize they have it.

        Pierre Charchaflian: 100%.

        Stacy Sherman: That seems so obvious, yet companies are challenged. They’re having such a [00:05:00] struggle with this. Why?

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah, I think there are several reasons. You know, if you ask CMOs today, and even if you ask CEOs today, we just did a CMO study about a year ago. We launched it in the summer of last year, IBM did. And we asked CMOs, “What are your top concerns?” And you’d think they would talk about advertising, they’d talk about creative, or budgets, which they always talk about budgets, obviously. But the number one concern they have is their technology stack and being able to deliver that dependable, consistent customer experience, but also a technology stack that allows them to innovate. I think their hands are tied a lot of the time in that they don’t have the right modern technology to do it. So that was top of the list. I think that’s a challenge. Another challenge that was cited: over 80% of CMOs cited data privacy concerns and trust issues, right? How do I [00:06:00] deliver and how do I anticipate your needs while earning your trust at the same time? How do we collect the right data from you? So I think that’s another challenge. A third challenge that was cited is organizational silos and talent, right? How do you solve that? And for us to deliver a comprehensive customer experience, it’s beyond the personalization of a salutation. It’s beyond the personalization of an offer or content. It’s really to deliver that personalized end-to-end experience, including the product experience. So being able to personalize your hotel visit, being able to personalize your trip. I’m using a travel example. But being able to personalize how we ship a product to you, and all of that. So that requires really end-to-end orchestration across all functions within the organization. So I think CMOs don’t lack vision. I think they lack sometimes budget, and they lack also the right technology in their hands to help them [00:07:00] deliver on that promise and that vision. And that’s where IBM comes in and tries to help and solve some of that complexity for our clients. But certainly those are probably the top challenges that CMOs are having.

        Stacy Sherman: Well, another thing I’m seeing as a challenge, going back to the silos statement earlier, is that we have human silos, we’ve got data silos, and now we’re almost having this AI silo problem because we’re deploying so many different tools. I remember working at a couple of corporations where they had the most sophisticated technology, but none of them interfaced with each other. And so, how do you get around that?

        Pierre Charchaflian: I think it takes a couple of things. I think you need to have the vision and you need to have the leadership in place. I’ll give you a great example. Telco. I was meeting with an AT&T executive at Mobile Congress in Barcelona about three months ago, and he said the number one reason why customers leave a network [00:08:00] is the quality of the network. So being able to anticipate that Stacy had, or continues to have, a bad network connection, right? That really allows a marketer or an experienced executive to say, “I want to do something about that for Stacy.” Now that data is there. That data is residing in the logs. But to get that data out of the logs and create an insight that is attached to Stacy’s profile so we can act upon it, is a lot of work. It takes an executive that is willing to do that, that convinces the organization and marshals the organization to actually act upon that and prove the ROI around it. That is what is really needed. So I would say executive leadership and convincing the organization to become more customer-driven and really operating based on customer-driven principles is really, to me, the number one ingredient that differentiates [00:09:00] the organizations that deliver on really best-in-class CX and Doing CX Right versus others that don’t. Does that make sense?

        Stacy Sherman: It does, especially because you didn’t realize that I worked at AT&T for 12 years or longer, and Verizon for five or six years. So telecom, I know it well.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah, yeah.

        Stacy Sherman: I know it very well. Now, leadership is clearly a huge factor here, and they are the ones who need to implement the technology to anticipate needs and bring the organization together. You have a report about “Winning the Moment.” There’s a lot of really good data in that. Can you share what stands out to you?

        Pierre Charchaflian: You know, “Winning the Moment” was a response to anxiety among our executives around two things. This thing called agentic: what do I do with it? What does it mean from a customer experience [00:10:00] standpoint? And the other was, “We’ve got all these agentic search engines. How do we win within that, but also how do we win despite that?” Because here’s the thing: agentic search engines are both a great opportunity for us to enhance our content and information architecture on our website so we can show up higher, but also there’s a threat. These search engines are pretty smart. They’re anticipating our needs. They’re understanding and decoding our intent. So there is a huge threat, in my opinion, that at some point they’ll take over conducting not only the search for us, but actually transacting on our behalf, and almost in a way threatening the core existence of a brand’s digital entity, organization, or store. So what do brands do in that context? How do brands win in that battle? And so the whole report was really about what do I do [00:11:00] to really win in this sort of environment, and what does the future of CX look like? And it’s really about decoding customer intent as one of the key principles. And decoding customer intent not only comes down to asking you a few questions, or looking at the log to see what products you looked at so I can give you an offer based on that. But actually it was about gaining the trust with you, Stacy, so I know from you what your favorite color is, what your favorite cuisine is, and what are some of the key preferences that you have so I can tailor the experience for you based on those preferences. That is a huge element of the future of customer experience. And how do I feed that into an agentic engine that says, “Based on Stacy’s preferences, I think she would like this outfit, or she would like this trip, or she’d like this mobile plan since she worked in telecom,” and so on and so forth. So it was really about how do brands win in the future [00:12:00] in the age of agentic and generative AI.

        Stacy Sherman: So agentic, how would you define that? Because there are a lot of different people using it in different contexts.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah. Without geeking out on it, to me, at the end of the day, what agentic does is it allows an agentic transformation of a workflow. Think of it as intelligent workers. It’s the replacement of people that are making decisions based on inputs of data to orchestrate a process or a workflow on behalf of someone. So we are doing it today in terms of going onto a ChatGPT and trying to answer a question. But it actually goes beyond that, well beyond that. It can go in and say, “I placed an order,” and then agentic looks at the order. It is intelligent enough to go and check in the warehouse and say, “Wait a second, do I have that product? If I don’t have that product, I’ll come back and make a recommendation for Pierre about a substitute product.” Or it can say, “Hey, you’re going on vacation. I can’t get you that product on time. How about if I ship [00:13:00] that package to your destination?” So it’s the intelligent orchestration of tasks together to achieve a process and replace humans. Now imagine doing that without gen AI: a person would have to go through that process, reason, and come back. Almost like a clerk in a store: “I don’t have that product. If you give me the address of where you’re going, I can ship it to you.” But imagine doing all of that through an agentic application that does that. We are on the cusp of probably the most exciting transformation of customer experience that I’ve seen, and I’ve seen many transformations. I would say we’re on the cusp of really, really transforming how brands interact with customers. So to me, agentic is an intelligent digital co-worker, a digital worker that can make decisions and execute not just a task, but an entire workflow on behalf of you as a customer or you as an [00:14:00] employee.

        Stacy Sherman: On a small scale, I’ve been using it a lot in the way of Claude Cowork. And for people that know Claude, you’ll know exactly what I mean, and for those that don’t, it’s incredible. I mean, it’s looking at my computer, and it’s doing tasks and working with me and analyzing stuff and writing comments in my documents. It truly is like I have a team of 10 people.

        Pierre Charchaflian: I think it’s truly transformative, and I think we’re just merely scratching the surface of the potential of what it can do.

        Stacy Sherman: Yes, absolutely. When we talk about the functions and tasks that are saved by agentic AI and it’s orchestrated across an entire customer journey, where does, in your opinion, the emotional level and the sentiments come into play? Because we know that humans are emotional beings, and we [00:15:00] can’t ignore that, but yet AI is robotic.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah, it’s a good question. I haven’t thought about the emotional being of a customer. I think that to me is a higher-level frontier of customer trust and intimacy. And I think customers, if we build the right trust with a customer, the customer can share that information with us, and we can be able to customize and personalize our experience based on that. But I think it’s a bit too dangerous to have gen AI try to interpret the emotional state of someone. Gen AI is very smart, but it’s also limited by the data that it can ingest and act upon. So I would say I’m going to trust that if a customer is giving a brand a certain level of data and we’re responding with that data in the context that is delivering value to that customer, that we’re going to be delivering on that emotional being or emotional state of a customer. Maybe you can elaborate a little more on that so I can answer in a different context, Stacy.

        Stacy Sherman: Yeah, well, what you said is very fair. I’ll shed a little light on that in terms of using AI to look at all of your customer conversations — both structured data like the surveys and the customer service calls, feeding the system all that information — as well as the unstructured conversations on social media and rating reviews. [00:16:00] Bringing that all together, AI can actually detect the positive and negative frustrations and use that to anticipate: is someone going to leave? Are people talking about a lawsuit? And predict: this is going to be costly. We’ve got to get bells ringing.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yes. No, for sure. I did build a solution for one of the largest automotive retailers in the country of basically doing just that. Taking their customer satisfaction survey, right, and being able to take that content and feed it into a gen [00:17:00] engine and say, “Okay, what’s the tonality of that content? Is it angry? Is it happy? Is it frustrated? Is it satisfied? Is it elated?” And being able to come back and do two things. Number one, speak back to the customer in the tone that is appropriate. But also build the next action to say, “I need to route this comment to operations. I need to route this comment to marketing. I need to route this comment to store ops,” and so on and so forth. So I think gen AI could play a really, really good role in deciphering that. Again, it does have the ability to really understand intent and meaning and being able to make intelligent decisions based on it. So for sure, Stacy.

        Stacy Sherman: Yeah, I recommend every person listening make sure that you are measuring the positive and negatives, you’re using the tools and technology to save you time in analyzing, and then using those insights. It’s really powerful. On [00:18:00] that note, do you have a favorite metric to measure customer experience in this day and age, outside the traditional Net Promoter Score and CSAT?

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah. I mean, to me, I’m a behavioralist, right? Customers can say yes and no, but at the end of the day, what matters is what they do. To me, it does come down to engagement. It does come down to transactions. It does come down to visits. Ultimately, that’s what matters at the end of the day. We could have the happiest customers, but if they’re not buying from us, that’s a missed opportunity. I go back to conversion. I go back to conversion as the number one metric that matters at the end of the day, right? If I get someone to buy — price, quality, satisfaction, loyalty, all of those — that conversion is the moment of truth. And I think everything else is secondary, with all honesty. So I always have that conversion number. Again, you can drive traffic to a website, [00:19:00] and top of the funnel could be great, but at the end of the day, a brand doesn’t make money until someone buys. So I’m very keen on that conversion number because, like I said, it’s really the moment of truth in a relationship.

        Stacy Sherman: Leadership. As a leader, you’ve been with many teams. You’ve also had bosses of your own. When you think about it all, what’s the best leadership advice you’ve ever received or been given?

        Pierre Charchaflian: One of the things that one of my first bosses ever said to me, and I repeat it to everyone, is: “Go figure out your T model.” Right? Your T model, as in the letter T, meaning for you to be successful, you have to be good at a lot of things that your job requires. But you’ve got to pick that one thing that you’re an expert in, that you have passion around. And if you can’t find it, you’re never going to be happy in your job, and you’re going to compromise your success. So I would say the best advice that I’ve been given, and the advice that I give to everyone that I [00:20:00] work with and that works in my organization, is find your T model. It’s okay not to be great at everything, but find that one thing that you are really going to be the expert in and find that passion around it. Because at the end of the day, we all have jobs, and a lot of the tasks in our job don’t make us get out of bed in the morning. But it’s that one dimension that allows us to have passion. From a leadership perspective, I think you’ve got to do two things. One, you’ve got to give people the vision. You’ve got to tell them where you’re going. That’s always been a trait of mine — communicating the purpose of what we’re doing today and really allowing people to operate freely with that guiding light of where we’re going. And most of the time, people end up performing really well in that environment. So I would say those two things are what have always stuck with me and that I’ve always shared with everyone else.

        Stacy Sherman: Currently, right now, when you’re talking about vision, and earlier in our conversation you [00:21:00] spoke about the importance of anticipation of customer needs and designing those experiences. Would you say that is the vision that you’re communicating, that you’re striving for?

        Pierre Charchaflian: Absolutely. With every CMO that I’m working with right now, there are really two visions that we’re driving. One is an internal vision and one is external. The internal vision is all around how do I transform my marketing operations with this new technology that’s emerging, so I can maximize the efficiency with generative AI. We know that generative AI can create content. We know generative AI can make decisions. So with that, there are tremendous opportunities to reduce costs. With that efficiency gained, how do I take those cost savings and that incremental investment and really place it in transforming the customer experience? Because I talk to CMOs all the time, and nobody’s getting [00:22:00] significant increases in budgets. As a matter of fact, the name of the game is cut, cut, cut. So CMOs have to find a way to fund their own growth. And we’re finding the message and the passion around two things. One is how do you reduce your cost and leverage this technology to drive efficiencies in the process? But the growth is going to come from how do I take that investment and really invest it in transforming my customer experience, so I can anticipate the needs of my customers, so I can deliver that personalization, and I increase the conversion of my customers? That’s really the agenda that we’re driving, and I think it’s getting a lot of traction. And the sequence matters as well: really drive the efficiency to fuel the growth of the brand.

        Stacy Sherman: And get ahead of it.

        Pierre Charchaflian: 100%. Yeah, for sure.

        Stacy Sherman: My last question, my favorite one. I’ve asked over 200 people. Pierre, if you could go back in time and talk to your younger 20-year-old self, based on what you know now that you didn’t know then, what would you say [00:23:00] to the younger you?

        Pierre Charchaflian: I would say take more risks. When you’re young, you can afford to take risks. Take risks with your career, take risks with endeavors, take risks even within your job. And if you have your passion driving that risk, I think you’re going to be okay. In your 20s, you’re going to have a lot more time to make up. Even if you make a mistake, you’re going to be so much smarter from the mistake that you made and the lessons that you’ve learned. So I would say take more risks, and with hard work, and as long as the risks are coming from the right source — from passion — you’re going to be more than okay.

        Stacy Sherman: I’ll need to play this for my young adult children in their 20s.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Maybe they can talk to my young children in their 20s, because they don’t listen to me.

        Stacy Sherman: Well, that is true. I think about what I knew then and I didn’t look at time in that I had so much more going forward, [00:24:00] and that I could take the risks. But yeah, it’s a really good topic. It could be an hour conversation.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yeah, for sure. For sure. I wish I took more risks, whether that’s starting my own business, or taking an idea to my boss that I was just too afraid to do, or actually going and building something on my own time and sharing it. There are a lot of ways to take risks without being foolish, obviously, that I think could have some good rewards and really good learning experiences as well.

        Stacy Sherman: Yeah. And to kids who are in college, I heard a saying which is really good about risk, and that is: be really smart when you’re doing dumb things.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Yes. That would be a risk. Yes, that’s a good idea of a risk.

        Stacy Sherman: Yes. Well, thank you, Pierre, so much for being here, and I will share more about the Winning the Moment report and you and all about IBM’s [00:25:00] newest, latest, greatest things in the show notes. So thank you for being here.

        Pierre Charchaflian: Thank you, Stacy, and thank you for having me.

        Customer Experience Questions & Answers: Anticipation, Agentic AI, and What Leaders Need to Know

        Q: What is agentic AI, and why does it matter for customer experience leaders?

        A: Agentic AI refers to systems that execute entire workflows autonomously, making decisions at each step rather than answering a single question or completing a single task. In a customer experience context, that means a system that detects a customer signal, reasons through the appropriate response, decides on an action, and executes it without a human approving each step. A customer places an order, the product is out of stock, and instead of returning an error, the agentic system checks the customer’s travel schedule and offers to ship the order to their hotel destination. That chain of detection, reasoning, decision, and action is what makes anticipation at scale possible. No human team can replicate that manually across an entire customer base.

        Q: What is the difference between personalization and anticipation in CX?

        A: Personalization looks at what a customer did and serves up something relevant to that behavior. You browsed running shoes, so the next page shows running shoes. Anticipation looks at what a customer is trying to accomplish and builds the full experience around that intent before the customer has to express it. It is not recommending a blue shirt because someone browsed shirts. It is curating an entire outfit because the system understands what the person is building toward. Personalization responds. Anticipation gets ahead. The customer experience that results from anticipation is emotionally different, and that difference is what drives the loyalty, referrals, and retention that show up in revenue.

        Q: What is IBM’s “Winning the Moment” report and what does it tell CX leaders?

        A: The report addresses how brands can compete and win in an environment where agentic AI tools and agentic search engines are fundamentally reshaping customer experience. It covers how to use generative AI to transform internal marketing operations, how to build customer-facing anticipation capability, and how brands need to think about trust and data when AI agents begin transacting on behalf of customers. The central argument is that brands which earn customer trust now will be the ones those customers authorize their AI agents to engage with. Brands that have not built that trust will not be in the consideration set when the transaction happens.

        Q; What is blocking most companies from anticipating customer needs even when the data exists?

        A: IBM’s CMO research identified three primary barriers. Technology stack limitations ranked first: most companies do not have the modern, connected infrastructure required to take data from one system and act on it in another in real time. Data privacy concerns ranked second, with over 80% of CMOs naming it as a genuine barrier to how they can use the data they have. Organizational silos ranked third, with human silos, data silos, and now AI silos, where different AI tools deployed across different functions are not connected to each other, all compounding the problem. The data to anticipate customer needs often already exists. What does not exist is the chain from that data to a person or system authorized and equipped to act on it.

        Q: Why is conversion the most important CX metric, and what are NPS and CSAT missing?

        A: NPS and CSAT measure what customers say about their experience. Conversion measures what they did. A company generates no revenue until a customer completes a purchase, and that behavioral signal is the actual test of whether the customer experience is working. A brand can have strong satisfaction scores and still be losing customers to competitors who are doing a better job of anticipating what those customers need at the moment of decision. Tracking conversion alongside behavioral metrics such as repeat purchase rate and churn rate by segment gives a more complete picture of what your CX is producing in revenue terms, which is the language leadership teams fund.

        Q: How can AI detect customer emotion and use it to prevent churn?

        A: AI systems can analyze structured data from surveys and CSAT scores alongside unstructured data from service call transcripts, chat logs, social media comments, and online reviews. Generative AI can read the tonality of that content at scale: identifying whether a customer is frustrated, satisfied, or at risk, in ways that no human team could replicate manually across thousands of interactions. Once those signals are detected, an agentic system can trigger the appropriate response, route the case to the right internal team, or initiate a proactive outreach before the customer decides to leave. The technology to do this exists. The gap for most companies is the workflow to act on what the technology surfaces.

        Q: What role does executive leadership play in CX transformation when the technology already exists?

        A: The technology to anticipate customer needs is increasingly available. What determines whether a company deploys it in a customer-driven way is executive leadership. Pierre’s example is precise: the data showing that a specific customer has had poor network quality for six weeks is already in the system logs. What does not exist in most companies is an executive willing to cross the organizational lines required to connect that data to a marketing or service action. That requires someone who will make the business case, fund the infrastructure, and hold functions accountable for acting on customer signals rather than keeping data in the system it originated in. Technology does not do that. Leaders do.

         

        About Pierre Charchaflian:

        Pierre is a marketing thought leader at the intersection of customer strategy, Customer experience,  digital transformation, data, and technology.  With over 25 years experience in helping fortune 500 companies define, design, and execute their marketing and customer strategies across an ever evolving digital landscape, Pierre is a seasoned business executive who always delivers client results. Connect with Pierre on LinkedIn.

        About Stacy Sherman:‬

        An award-winning international Certified Speaking Professional (CSP) who has delivered more than 100 standing ovation keynotes and workshops and co-authored best-selling books on Experience Management for sustainable success. She developed a proprietary framework that enables leaders and teams to enhance revenue and brand reputation. Her proven methodology is based on her MBA degree and 25 years of leadership in sales, marketing, employee, and customer experience across diverse industries, including Verizon, AT&T, Schindler Elevator Corporation, Wilton Brands, Martha Stewart Crafts, and LiveOps, generating $2.4 billion in savings and hundreds of millions in revenue. Stacy Sherman has earned widespread recognition for her award-winning “Doing CX Right” podcast, ranked in the top 2% globally with over 200 episodes, and for her courses on LinkedIn Learning, which have garnered hundreds of 5-star reviews. A multi-year Global CX Guru awardee and 2026 ICMI Hall of Fame inductee, Stacy’s insights have been featured in Forbes, Psychology Today, Yahoo News, and other leading publications.

         

        Need help? Let’s talk.

        Change Management Employee Retention  Leadership Development  Workplace Culture Customer Experience Customer Service voice of customer artificial intelligence community customer loyalty CX

        How To Build An Effective Customer Loyalty Program: Lessons From IKEA

        How To Build An Effective Customer Loyalty Program: Lessons From IKEA

        Doing CX Right podcast show on Spotify with host Stacy Sherman
        DoingCXRight-Podcast-on-Amazon-with-host-Stacy-Sherman.
        Doing Customer Experience (CX) Right Podcast - Hosted by Stacy Sherman
        Doing CX Right podcast show on iHeart Radio with host Stacy Sherman

            Most business leaders track traditional metrics such as NPS, Customer Satisfaction (CSAT), and average response time. They are, however, overlooking the single factor that reliably predicts customer return, referrals, increased spending, and the willingness to forgive a mistake: emotion.

            This episode focuses on proving the cost of this emotion gap and detailing the actions leaders must take now to achieve lasting success.

            Stacy Sherman speaks to Isabelle Zdatny at Qualtrics XM Institute about in-depth research that reveals what separates companies that earn customer loyalty from those that keep losing it without knowing why.

            What You Will Learn About Earning Customer Loyalty:

            • How to identify the one emotion your brand must stand for and turn it into a metric your leadership team will act on
            • Why customers with high emotion ratings are exponentially more likely to trust, forgive a mistake, and recommend your brand than any functional metric currently predicts
            • What a four-year longitudinal study of publicly traded companies reveals about the stock performance gap between emotion leaders and emotion laggards
            • Why AI deployed in customer service is eroding trust faster than it is creating efficiency, and what to do instead
            • How one company stopped measuring satisfaction entirely, created a proprietary metric tied to executive compensation, and changed how their entire organization operated
            • What behavioral signals inside your existing call recordings and chat transcripts are already telling you about how customers feel that post-transaction surveys will never capture

            Actionable Customer Experience and Loyalty Takeaways:

            1. Stop framing loyalty as a cost center when presenting to the C-suite.
            2. Audit whether your loyalty program and support team share the same customer data.
            3. Build a customer journey map before designing any loyalty initiative.
            4. Define the value exchange before you ask customers for their data.
            5. Replace tier structures with membership status.
            6. Measure engagement depth, not just transaction activity.
            7. Rotate which team leads at each stage of the customer journey.
            8. Use AI to increase message relevance, not message volume.
            9. Prepare your brand for the agent-to-agent economy now.
            10. Go through your own customer experience regularly.

             

            Press Play  To WATCH On Youtube

            Doing CX Right Podcast Topics with Timestamps

            [00:01:00] What customer experience means when viewed through a loyalty lens

            [00:02:30] Why organizational silos are a customer experience problem, not just an internal one

            [00:04:00] How journey mapping closes the gap between departments

            [00:05:30] Making the financial case for loyalty investment to the C-suite

            [00:08:00] Why loyalty programs have become a cliché and what to do instead

            [00:10:30] The metrics that confirm whether a loyalty program is working

            [00:11:30] Where emotion belongs in customer experience design

            [00:13:30] How AI changes the design of loyalty and personalization programs

            [00:14:30] The agent-to-agent economy and what it means for brand trust

            [00:18:30] IKEA’s approach: starting every program with brand values

            Read Full Episode Transcript

            Stacy Sherman: [00:00:00] Hello, Martin. Welcome to the Doing CX Right show.

            Martin Villanueva: Thank you. Thank you for having me.

            Stacy Sherman: I am thrilled to have you, and it’s also really cool because you’re in Amsterdam and I’m in the United States, and we are so far apart, yet I feel so close to you right now.

            Martin Villanueva: Thank you. Me too. We had a really nice conversation before recording, right?

            Stacy Sherman: Yeah. Yeah, we did, and so now it’s time to let the audience hear our fabulous thoughts together. But before we do, can you give a little glimpse of who you are? What do you do professionally?

            Martin Villanueva: So I’m Martin, originally from Argentina, living in Amsterdam, as you said, and I work for IKEA.

            I have a global role. I’m responsible for personalization and loyalty in this IKEA world.

            Stacy Sherman: IKEA, I know the brand very well, and a customer of IKEA for many years, and I bet many listeners will say the same. So we’ll dive into what makes people loyal to IKEA and some of the work you do. But before, what is a fun fact [00:01:00] about you that people might not know?

            Martin Villanueva: Something that people don’t know. Well, that I work at anything I could in Australia. I even cleaned toilets in a hotel, for example, or I was a Spanish teacher in Australia, or I sold used secondhand cars as well. So like I did so many things which made me go out and experience a lot of stuff.

            Stacy Sherman: Wow, cleaning toilets and these other roles.

            I guess you were delivering a customer experience without really defining it at that time. Yeah, totally. So when I say doing customer experience right, what does that mean to you from the lens of loyalty and customer retention?

            Martin Villanueva: I work for many brands, for many big- Mm-hmm … huge corporations, most brands in the world, Nike, Adidas, McDonald’s, and now IKEA, and what I’ve noticed is that many of them separate CX over here, loyalty over there, service in another team, and personalization somewhere else.

            But customers don’t experience companies or brands in silos, right? They experience one brand only. If your loyalty program [00:02:00] says, “We know you. Thank you for sharing this data with us,” but then you go to customer support and it says- Well, can you start over and explain everything again? That’s not loyalty, that’s fragmentation, right?

            So the brands that do this right can create an actual experience where every touchpoint reinforces the same feeling, right? So that’s how I will see CX done right. When you feel that the brand gets you, that it helps you, and it makes your life better, that’s what I will say it’s a good CX.

            Stacy Sherman: Yes, and I also say that customers do not care about your org chart.

            No. But yet silos is everywhere. I’ve worked for over 25 years in corporate and mid-size companies. So when you say that silos is problematic, and I agree, how do you stop that? Can you stop that?

            Martin Villanueva: It’s very difficult, and of course, you were talking about org charts and people, and people in corporate that we do this every single day.

            And I think it’s one of the biggest challenges around how you can stop those silos to [00:03:00] happen because everybody in any company wants to do their job right, and they have their own objectives, and they want to reach out to those OKRs from the inside, right? But from the outside, it’s not what the customers will see.

            They will see silos. I guess what you can do is just to try to align strategies and try to get to the same objective if you can and try to merge it as you can. Nowadays, I work on personalization, for example, and we always say personalization can be everywhere or it can be nowhere because it’s so broad.

            Yeah, be aligned to many topics like loyalty, customer support, marketing, you name it. So we are trying to find those alignments within those areas to have a unique experience, seamless experience.

            Stacy Sherman: Alignment is a great word. The way I would create alignment across the different departments is through a tool of journey mapping.

            Has that been something you’ve done or found valuable?

            Martin Villanueva: Absolutely. That’s one of the first things I did in my role at [00:04:00] Ikea. We built a full customer journey within different customers, putting on each moment of interaction with the consumers which opportunity we could apply for loyalty and for personalizations.

            When you are scrolling on your phone and your, uh, social media, since that moment to when you actually do a purchase in store and you buy a hotdog when you leave. So we did all these experiments and all this, uh, mapping, and it really, really helped us.

            Stacy Sherman: And for listeners, you might be saying, “Well, what does journey mapping have to do with silos?”

            Well, the answer is that by bringing every department together into the same room and mapping out walking in the customer’s shoes, how they learn, buy, get, use, pay, get help, every role understands the domino effect and how they affect each other. So I love, Martín, that you said you do that, and it’s so important.

            Martin Villanueva: Yeah, totally agree. And one thing that we all need to understand in the industry is that sometimes personalization will lead, [00:05:00] sometimes loyalty will lead, sometimes customer support will lead. So if we get that right, everybody will know their role and their part in each moment of that interaction, and that’s putting the customer in the center, right?

            It’s not putting the topic in the center.

            Stacy Sherman: So research has shown that companies spend so much more money to acquire a new customer, and they’re focusing on acquiring new, getting new than retaining an existing customer. It’s like they’re not loving the ones they have, in, to quote myself. Yeah. Most budgets are still skewed towards acquisition, and we know that loyalty is important.

            Yet a lot of those in roles like you and I have that we have to make the financial case to the C-suite that loyalty programs deserve an investment. So first question is: What’s your advice how to get the C-suite to believe that loyalty matters, that you need to [00:06:00] focus on loyalty programs?

            Martin Villanueva: That’s a great question, and it’s part of what I’ve been doing in, in these last 15 years with all these companies.

            It, it’s a key question, and it, maybe it’s difficult to apply it. But first of all, I will try to move the conversation away from loyalty as a cost center, you know, as something that will bring costs, and bring it towards loyalty as a growth engine. Because when loyalty is done right, it improves multiple levers at once.

            So you can think about frequency, basket size, retention, CLTV, advocacy, first data, quality, you name it. There are several metrics that it can improve. So when I talk with executives and I have these conversations, my first question was why loyalty often gets underfunded, right? And, and it’s not because leaders disagree with it.

            I think everyone agrees that loyalty programs are really, really important. But I think sometimes it gets framed as a, a nice-to-have marketing layer, you know, instead of a business model multiplier. It will multiply your business in many ways. So I usually make the case, I use, like, maybe three, four [00:07:00] models or conversation topics to change this around.

            The first one is the retention economics. We all know that keeping customers longer generally improves profitability, right? And it’s more efficient to do this than to replace churn with new acquisition. So that’s the first one, and there is no battling against it. I mean, it makes sense, and it’s in lo- in all the books, right?

            Second is the behavioral value. Loyal customers don’t just buy more, but they trust you more. They, they forgive you more of the things that the brand, uh, maybe is doing wrong or is not doing correctly. So they engage more. They give you permission to know them better, so that’s amazing as well. So there’s your behavioral value within.

            And then the strategic, maybe resilience about it. It’s, acquisition is getting more expensive day by day. We all know that. So attention is fragmented. I can experience myself on social media, right? AI will make comparison even easier. So retentions becomes a defensive, a defensive layer. I think also really, really important to understand.

            If you don’t invest in loyalty, you’re choosing to rent your growth instead of owning it, you know? So [00:08:00] Yeah, that’s what I would say.

            Stacy Sherman: When we talk about loyalty, I feel like it’s so overused, it’s becoming cliche. Yes. It is. So how can we reframe that? What could we help the audience listeners understand when we say loyalty, even loyalty programs, what are we talking about from your perspective?

            Martin Villanueva: I think it’s getting a cliche because all loyalty programs today are reward systems. I truly believe that. When they should be designing loyalty programs as relationship systems, right? So you go from rewards to relationships, and that, I think that’s the biggest cliche ever, and people are not understanding it completely.

            They give discounts. They start with maybe a birthday email, maybe a tier structure. Remember when I worked at Nike, we had all these tiers, and we tried to simplify the program. So now it was called Nike+ and now it’s just called Nike Membership because that’s it. Everybody that buys at Nike and it’s a member receives the same benefits.

            It’s a relationship status. It’s not that I’m gonna treat you differently, right? And that’s not nice in a [00:09:00] relationship. That’s what I do every single day when I interact with a brand. Like, why should I share my data with you? We are not thinking as customers, because I am a customer, too. How many points do I get per euro?

            Like airlines, for example. How many points do I get? That’s an example that we all do, but then mostly we are focused on relationships with customers.

            Stacy Sherman: Why should I have a relationship with you? I wanna pause on that. That is such a important point. Now, as customers, we’re not actually saying that to ourselves out loud.

            Mm. If neuroscience and psychologists were here, they probably could really lend some insights here that that is really what’s going on in our minds as we think and feel- Hmm … at every interaction.

            Martin Villanueva: It’s also a hot topic. In every conference I go or I speak, professionals tend to speak about relationships, right?

            Like emotional loyalty. That’s also a, a very hot topic nowadays, but I don’t think everybody’s getting it correctly because a relationship should be both ways. It’s not [00:10:00] just one way, and that’s how I would start answering your question. How do you generate trust with another person, for example? It’s by sharing both of you- Things of yourself, things that you actually care about, and then you start building that trust and start sharing more with the other person.

            And I think that’s exactly what is happening or, or what should happen with brands. Like, we should actually get to an instance of trust with a brand. I hope we can get it with Ikea. I think we have a really good brand trust. That’s where it should be, based in trust, and that’s how you build a relationship, and that’s what we are pursuing.

            Stacy Sherman: So pursuing, how do you know that your loyalty initiatives are working? What are your favorite metrics to actually know that you’re doing it right?

            Martin Villanueva: Many. I will say customer lifetime value could be one of my favorite ones. To go a step below, I should say I like metrics that connect behavior, economics, and the emotional and strength that it builds.

            So I care about the classics, of course, repeat purchase rate, frequency, CLTV, as I mentioned, active member rate, churn. But I also want to [00:11:00] know, and I also will also pursue and, uh, try to understand, are members getting more engaged over time, for example? That’s a question I, I make myself. Are we increasing relevance, not just activity?

            Because activity is, it’s not a good indicator, right? That we are actually getting more from the customers. That’s another question I do. It’s like, are we earning more permission from customers to personalize? And that’s a signal of trust. That’s what I was talking about before. It’s like, are they actually sharing more data with us?

            Are we asking them questions and they are replying? Are we reducing friction in service and experience? So maybe they are soft questions, but I think they are really important.

            Stacy Sherman: You mentioned a word before and I wanna dig into emotion. Say more. How is emotion important in business and even in the loyalty initiatives that you’re working on?

            Because a lot of companies say emotions don’t matter. They’re very transactional. They’re very profit-driven. So where does emotion come into this?

            Martin Villanueva: Of course, emotions are different from person to person or human to [00:12:00] human. They are different than a brand to human or human to brand. I think we all expect when we have a level of trust with a brand is to get some value from it, and that value will bring me some emotions.

            If a brand knows me or I, I share with a brand data for the brand to know me and understand me, what I’m expecting is some value for me which will bring me better choices, better life, better commitment to the brand. So I kind of relate emotion to value.

            Stacy Sherman: When you’ve done a journey mapping with your teams, where does emotion come into that exercise?

            Martin Villanueva: Not specifically. We, we don’t put emotion in the, in every single touchpoint because that will feel creepy. You know what I mean? If we think about getting emotional connections in every single touchpoint of the journey, it will start feeling like too much. It’s like when you ask chatGPT for answers and it says Oh, that’s amazing, Martin.

            You– Good job. And at some point, you start feeling like, well, stop talking like that. You know? Like, stop telling me, like, being so soft and gentle with me. It’s not [00:13:00] true. It’s not how I want to experience this. Try just to be human, human-centric, and then understanding the consumers from another perspective, which, yeah, that brings emotions.

            That brings good vibes and good intentions. And so that’s the spirit, you know, when you talk about emotion.

            Stacy Sherman: My two cents is, and I agree with what you’re saying, when you are designing the experiences at these micro moments, you do have to ask yourself as a team, are we creating a positive or negative experience, that emotional connection to the brand?

            So it may not be specifically happy, overjoyed. You know, like, it, it can get a bit over the top. But as a rule, it has to be positive at every micro moment. So let me ask you this: AI. How does AI affect these loyalty programs and designing these initiatives? Is AI a factor? Is it helpful or not?

            Martin Villanueva: Absolutely, and mostly for personalization.

            Personalization will [00:14:00] be the base of a- any loyalty program in the near future. Maybe next year should be the average for e- every big brand. And then you can’t personalize without AI, I think. But it’s not about just making it more efficient. It’s not about sending more personalized messages to more people.

            It’s about making it more relevant and more human, and that’s what we are aiming for at IKEA. We want to use AI in a way that it can be relevant to you and bring value to you, the consumer, in a human way. Because you can automate more generic messages faster, but it will be irrelevant, right? Last year, I focused in this keynote I, I did.

            The title was, “Can You Actually Fall in Love with a Brand?” How AI is changing the intimacy within brands and consumers. I touch upon the base of building trust. At some point, agents will speak to agents, right? So your agent, Stacy, will talk to any brand’s agent, and it will try to understand it, and it will try to buy things from it.

            So where does loyalty stands in that specific moment of loyalty, like agents talking to agents? So I think that trust will be the major [00:15:00] topic next year or even this one. How you can actually, as a human, say, “Hey, agent, you can trust IKEA. You can trust Nike. You can trust Adidas. This is a brand I trust.

            This is a brand that goes with my ideas, my values, so go just interact with it.” And I think that’s gonna be more difficult for brands coming in to play, rather than the ones that have already a reputation and have already trust built with consumers.

            Stacy Sherman: Yeah, and the reason this is so important, which is another whole conversation another day, is that AI is recommending brands.

            We’re becoming in a zero-click economy, and therefore what people say about your brand and those sentiments out in the public matter so much more than they ever did before. For someone listening who wants to start a loyalty program in their company, what’s your advice to them? What are two, three things they should go do right now?

            Martin Villanueva: Try not to think about rewards. Try not to think about promotions, discounts. Try to think about generating a connection with the [00:16:00] consumer. Focus on that. Focus on trying to understand that customer. So I think if you scale it, you can actually think about generating value to the consumers, and that’s what I would start.

            How do I generate the value to us, the consumers? That’s what I will start with

            Stacy Sherman: At IKEA, you know what works. Without giving any trade secrets away, is there something that IKEA’s really known for in team on some of the things you’re actually doing? Can you shed any light on that?

            Martin Villanueva: I think I said some stuff already, but IKEA is well known by generating the transparency and building trust with its consumers and everybody that enters to the store.

            So I think we try to follow these values in every single thing we do. You name it, personalization, loyalty, customer support, and being human. That’s also a very big value from IKEA, and that’s w- how we are well known, for being human. And that’s our biggest metric.

            Stacy Sherman: So to get tactical, you’re starting with values- Yeah

            and then making sure that everybody at every touchpoint is acting upon that shared [00:17:00] value. Is that what you’re saying?

            Martin Villanueva: Exactly like that. Values are- Okay … the starting point at IKEA.

            Stacy Sherman: Okay. So give us one more. You’ve got your values. Now you’re creating a program. You’re creating personalization. What’s something people can literally go do in terms of optimizing that loyalty program?

            Martin Villanueva: I think you start with the values, and you try to actually continue with the brand proposition and be an extension of the brand. From the values, you start building value to the customer. Why would I be sharing data with you? Why would I be sharing data with IKEA? Why would I share, as a customer, data with you if it’s not bringing me any value or it’s not bringing me anything to this relationship?

            I’m just sharing with you. What are you sharing with me? That, I will say that’s, uh, really, really important, and we really consider that.

            Stacy Sherman: So are you saying when you design any program, you are making sure that there’s a value exchange- Yeah … with that customer so that they want to give you their information?

            So you’re designing a program, that exchange is [00:18:00] easy, simple, and that they want to.

            Martin Villanueva: 100%, and that’s what I meant when I said a two-ways relationship.

            Stacy Sherman: All right, final questions. What is the most important takeaway you want people to remember from this conversation?

            Martin Villanueva: Build trust, build a program that it’s built to last, and always, always keep the customer in the center, and always put yourself as a customer.

            That’s what I do every single day.

            Stacy Sherman: Go be your customer. Get on the calls with your customer service team. Exactly. Oh, there’s so much to say on that. So

            Martin Villanueva: much to say, and, and, you know, at every IKEA office in the world, they are based in a store. So actually, every single day, we have to go through the store and see people interact and customers interact with our products in real time.

            Stacy Sherman: That’s well said, and I… Everybody listening can go do that. Go be your own customer and go observe. Love that. And leadership, best leadership advice you’ve ever received or given.

            Martin Villanueva: Try to move the needle when it will generate value. [00:19:00] Don’t try to shake status quo just for doing it. When I was younger, I wanted to change everything in my area.

            We should now put AI into working and changing everything radically, and the main questions came, and they were, like, very simple. Why would we do that if this is actually giving real good value? We should focus on things that will move the needle in the right direction, and not just doing it because it’s a trend.

            Stacy Sherman: I have to comment on that, because in my corporate life, there’d be so many reorganizations, and I felt like it, they were just changing for change. It wasn’t purposeful, and it was disruptive, and it was happening every six months. And so I love that point, and I hope that leaders listening to this understand that, that change just to change, it, it’s gotta be valuable, and learn from every change.

            Just don’t change just to say you did it.

            Martin Villanueva: Exactly. Exactly. Not everything needs to be changed every single time.

            Stacy Sherman: Yeah. And my favorite question of the entire show, if you could go back in time to your younger 20-year-old self, based [00:20:00] on what you know now that you didn’t know then, Martin, what would you say to the younger you?

            Martin Villanueva: I will tell me, my first thing is go do it. If the opportunity is out there, go do it and pursue it. Try everything you can try. Always healthy, stay healthy, but try everything, everything that, that you see as an opportunity, because you will learn from it, and you will get it right in the end. So that’s what I will say.

            Go for it. If you have to clean floors just to surf in the afternoon, go for it. If you need to sell cars just to buy a ticket to go and study in, uh, Hong Kong like I did, go for it. And then if you need to move across the world like I did with all my family from Argentina to Amsterdam to pursue another opportunity, do it.

            Life is too short, and I think it’s worth it to try.

            Stacy Sherman: To try, and I would say don’t even try, just do. Do it. Don’t try. Try is thinking. Try is pondering and hoping. You did it.

            Martin Villanueva: Yes, exactly. Just do it.

            Stacy Sherman: Just do it. Nike says that very well. Well, before we go, I [00:21:00] wanted you to tell one short story that I got the same thing from my mom growing up.

            Please, share your story about Mom.

            Martin Villanueva: So our conversation started off the record. Stacy asked me about my birth date, and I said, “Well, tomorrow is my 40 birthday,” which is quite a coincidence. But then she was doubting about her age, and she was, like, counting the years, et cetera, and I was like, “Well, my mom never said her own age.

            She always said she was 24.” And until we were 12, 14 years old, she was, like, still saying, “I’m turning 24.” And we still believed her at some point, but then we realized it didn’t. But then herely- Yeah … you have the same case.

            Stacy Sherman: So my mom every year would say, “I’m 21.” Then the next year, “I’m 21,” and then, “21.” And then eventually I got smart and I said, “Mom, you can’t be 21 every year.”

            And she said, “Oh, you’re right, I’m 21 plus this year.” 21 plus. And so that’s been the running joke. And so I love that our moms from all different parts of the [00:22:00] world have a great philosophy about age and youth.

            Martin Villanueva: Go moms. Go moms.

            Stacy Sherman: Well, thank you so much for being on this show, and I really appreciate you and your insights, and I’ll share all about you and ways to connect with you in the show notes.

            So thank you again.

            Martin Villanueva: Thank you, Stacy. It’s been a pleasure. Thank you so much.

            Customer Experience Questions & Answers To Boost Business Results

            Why do most customer loyalty programs fail to retain customers?
            Most loyalty programs are built as reward systems: points, tiers, and discounts. Those mechanics give customers a reason to calculate whether the program offers enough value to stay, rather than a reason to build a relationship with the brand. When a customer who has shared data with a loyalty program contacts support and is asked to re-explain their account history, the program has failed its basic purpose. The loyalty and support teams are operating on separate data, and the customer receives no benefit from the data they share. A program that does not return a specific, relevant value to the customer for the data they provide does not produce repeat purchasing behavior.

            How do you make the financial case for loyalty investment when the C-suite views it as a cost?
            Present loyalty as a growth engine using three arguments. First, retention economics: keeping an existing customer in an active purchasing relationship costs less than replacing a lost customer through new acquisition. Second, behavioral value: customers who return regularly buy more often, forgive brand errors more readily, and give the brand permission to collect more data over time, each of which has a direct effect on revenue per customer. Third, strategic resilience: acquisition costs are rising and AI is making product comparison faster, which means a business that does not invest in retention is paying acquisition costs repeatedly for the same revenue base.

            What is a value exchange in a loyalty program, and why does it matter?
            A value exchange is the explicit agreement between a brand and a customer about what the customer receives in return for sharing their data. Before any loyalty or personalization program asks customers for information, the program must define what specific value the customer receives in return. If that answer is not specific and immediate, customers will not share their data. Without that data, the personalization program cannot function, and the loyalty program has no basis for treating customers as individuals rather than transactions.

            How does AI affect customer loyalty programs?
            AI enables personalization at scale, but it does not automatically build loyalty. The risk is that brands use AI to send more automated messages to more customers faster, which increases volume without increasing relevance. A customer who receives frequent irrelevant messages does not build a relationship with the brand. The standard for AI use in a loyalty or personalization program is whether each message is more relevant to that specific customer, not whether it was delivered more efficiently. Additionally, as AI agents begin transacting on behalf of customers, the brands that have already established a relationship with those customers will be the ones those agents are authorized to engage. Brands that have not built that relationship will not be included.

            How do you measure whether a loyalty program is working beyond transaction counts?
            Track repeat purchase rate, purchase frequency, active member rate, and customer lifetime value as baseline metrics. Then add three behavioral questions: Are customers sharing more data with the brand over time in response to questions the brand asks? Are customers returning more frequently because the experience is relevant, not just because a promotion is running? Is the friction a customer encounters during a service interaction decreasing over successive contacts? Those three behavioral signals indicate that the customer has concluded the brand is worth continued engagement, which is the actual definition of loyalty as a business outcome.

            About Martin Villanueva:   

            Martin is a customer-focused growth leader with 18 years of experience driving loyalty, personalization, and data-driven engagement for global brands including McDonald’s, Nike, Adidas, and IKEA. He launched Nike+ in Latin America, built Adidas’ Europe-wide membership proposition, and currently leads IKEA’s global customer engagement strategy. His approach combines creativity, analytics, and technology to deepen the connection between brands and their customers through a test-and-learn operating method. A former university football captain and Australian Premier League player who still plays on weekends, Martin brings the same resilience and collaborative energy from the pitch to cross-functional leadership. His career across six continents, from Buenos Aires to Sydney to Amsterdam to New York, gives him a 360-degree view of both consumer behavior and talent development. Beyond his work at IKEA, Martin co-founded the European Loyalty Association Awards, where he serves as its “Chief ELAbrator.” He speaks regularly at industry conferences on customer engagement, AI-powered personalization, and loyalty program design. Connect with Martin on LinkedIn. 

             

            About Stacy Sherman:‬

            An award-winning international Certified Speaking Professional (CSP) who has delivered more than 100 standing ovation keynotes and workshops and co-authored best-selling books on Experience Management for sustainable success. She developed a proprietary framework that enables leaders and teams to enhance revenue and brand reputation. Her proven methodology is based on her MBA degree and 25 years of leadership in sales, marketing, employee, and customer experience across diverse industries, including Verizon, AT&T, Schindler Elevator Corporation, Wilton Brands, Martha Stewart Crafts, and LiveOps, generating $2.4 billion in savings and hundreds of millions in revenue. Stacy Sherman has earned widespread recognition for her award-winning “Doing CX Right” podcast, ranked in the top 2% globally with over 200 episodes, and for her courses on LinkedIn Learning, which have garnered hundreds of 5-star reviews. A multi-year Global CX Guru awardee and 2026 ICMI Hall of Fame inductee, Stacy’s insights have been featured in Forbes, Psychology Today, Yahoo News, and other leading publications.

             

            Need help? Let’s talk.

            Change Management Employee Retention  Leadership Development  Workplace Culture Customer Experience Customer Service voice of customer artificial intelligence community customer loyalty CX

            American Airlines Free Wi-Fi: Customer Experience Lessons You Can Apply

            American Airlines Free Wi-Fi: Customer Experience Lessons You Can Apply

            American Airlines just announced free, high-speed inflight Wi-Fi for AAdvantage members, sponsored by my past employer, AT&T. The rollout starts this month (January 2026) and is expected to reach most of the fleet by early spring.

            That is great news.

            But the headline isn’t really about bandwidth. It’s about correcting a massive imbalance in how companies treat their revenue source:

            Most companies keep chasing the next customer… while the ones funding the business get a “thanks for your order” and nothing else.

            The Loyalty Imbalance

            I’ve seen this across companies for a very long time:

            • New clients get the highest discounts.
            • New sign-ups get the best terms.
            • Loyal customers get the mediocre, standard rate.

            American Airlines is flipping that script.

            They are stepping up in a landscape where the bar is rising fast. United Airlines has already started offering free Wi-Fi on Starlink-equipped aircraft, and Delta Air Lines has been doing free Wi-Fi for loyalty members, too. (You can read more about these airline offers and policies in article by Zach Wichter in USA TODAY.

            So, is American too late?

            No.

            This isn’t a race to provide the best internet speed. It’s a strategic choice to fix a broken definition of “connection.”

            Connectivity vs. Connection

            In business, there are two types of connection. There is digital connectivity (the utility, the bandwidth, the internet). And there is emotional connection (the relationship, the feeling, the loyalty).

            The problem is that you cannot build a strong emotional connection while holding the digital connectivity hostage.

            Think about the signal a paywall sends: You are a loyal flier. You sit down in your seat, ready to work, but the airline blocks you. They ask for a credit card. This creates a negative interaction. It adds friction. It creates distance. It tells the customer: “We can connect you to the internet, but only if you pay a toll.”

            Now, look at the shift American is making. By removing the paywall, they are removing the friction. You sit down, and the internet is just… there. This creates a positive interaction. It removes the distance. It tells the customer: “We want you connected—to your work, to your family, and to us.”

            They decided that the relationship was worth more than the transaction fee.

            They are choosing to Love the ones they have℠. That is Doing CX Right℠. By removing the barrier, they proved they are willing to invest in the people who invest in them.

            That is how you become irreplaceable. You stack enough of these positive interactions together until the sum is so high that the customer wouldn’t dream of going anywhere else.

            Now the business lesson, even if you’re not in airlines: A perk isn’t the point. The signal is what matters. And the signal means: “We recognize you. Your loyalty changes how we treat you.”

            How to Find Your “Wi-Fi”

            My recommendation: Examine what you are doing to appreciate your existing customers who trust you. This requires knowing your customer at a deep level. You need to identify the friction they have learned to live with and make it disappear.

            In your industry, your “Wi-Fi” isn’t about bandwidth. It is about removing the “tax” you charge for loyalty.

            • In Retail: Maybe it’s the return policy. Stop asking your regulars for a receipt. You know them. You know they bought it.
            • In E-commerce: Maybe it’s the shipping speed. Stop holding back the “fast lane” for a surcharge. Give them the upgrade because they’ve earned it.
            • In B2B: Maybe it’s the clock. Stop running the meter on a five-minute phone call. Treat the advice as an investment, not an invoice.

            Whatever it is, identify the barrier that makes your best customers feel like strangers. Then, remove it.

            Give them the Wi-Fi equivalent in your business.

            Go find your Wi-Fi.

            Want more proven strategies to boost revenue and retention, let’s talk. 

            Still Measuring Customer Satisfaction? That Might Be the Problem

            Still Measuring Customer Satisfaction? That Might Be the Problem

            Imagine: You go out to dinner. The table’s clean. The food arrives on time. The service is polite. Nothing goes wrong.

            Later, someone asks, “How was it?” You pause. “It was fine.” That one word—fine—reveals everything. You probably wouldn’t return because ‘fine‘ is the everyday version of ‘satisfied, and that’s mediocre. That’s “average,” and people need and want more than that.  

            What Customer Satisfaction Signals (And Why It’s Not Enough)

            The Rolling Stones’ “I Can’t Get No Satisfaction” still plays nearly 60 years later—for a reason. It captured something true: the gap between what people expect—and what they get. That same tension is also evident in customer experience (CX).

            Satisfaction is often treated as a win. A green metric. A notification that everything is going well. But in reality, it means that nothing went wrong.

            And that’s the problem.

            It doesn’t indicate the experience was meaningful. It doesn’t mean the customer will come back. It definitely doesn’t mean they’ll recommend you. When my kids were younger—and even now as adults—if I asked how their day was and they said, “It was fine,” I never needed to ask more. I already knew: it wasn’t terrible, but it wasn’t fabulous either.

            That’s how satisfaction works. It captures the absence of pain, but not the presence of value. And companies won’t succeed in the long term without it.

            The Restaurant “Customer Satisfaction” Test:

            Would you put “satisfactory” on a sign outside your restaurant? Would you launch a campaign that says, “Come for a meal that won’t disappoint”? Would you report to your board, “Our customers describe us as fine”?

            Of course not.

            And yet, that’s exactly how many companies treat customer satisfaction scores. They chase and report them. Attach incentives to them too, and then wonder why customer retention is problematic. In reality, Satisfied customers leave all the time. Because satisfaction is neutral. It’s not negative, but it’s not enough to build loyalty.

            What Actually Predicts Customer Retention and Loyalty

            After 25 years of working in companies across various industries and listening to customers, here’s what I’ve learned: People come back because something made a lasting impression, not just because the basics were met. Something felt personal, thoughtful, and exceeded expectations.

            They remember:

            • When someone anticipated their need
            • When a problem was resolved before they noticed
            • When an interaction felt human—not transactional

            They use words like “impressed,” “surprised,” or “they really got me.” They tell stories about the experience—not just the outcome.

            And no one ever says, “I was satisfied.”

            If you’ve been using the customer satisfaction (C-Sat) metric, that’s okay. It served a purpose. For years, it gave teams a way to start paying attention to experience—and that mattered.

            But we’re living in a new era. Customers now require more, and have increasingly more ways to get what they need. AI has made comparing options faster. Switching is easier. And the best experience someone had last week now sets the bar for how they evaluate you.

            In that reality, “nothing went wrong” isn’t a reliable signal of loyalty. It’s just a low bar. One that doesn’t reflect how people actually make choices.

            If satisfaction is still your Customer eXperience measurement, you’re not alone. But it might be time to ask: What is it really telling you? And what is it missing?

            “(I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction” is a fantastic song. It’ll outlive all of us. It’s earned its place.

            But the metric?

            That’s the one I want you to really consider. Maybe—it’s time to retire it.

            Want to know better measurements and ways to design customer experiences the right way to boost retention, revenue, and referrals? Let’s talk.

            And, subscribe to my newsletter for ongoing actionable strategies delivered to your inbox.

             

            Listen to Doing CX Right Podcast

            Subscribe on your favorite channels.